Unpacking the controversial 'mugshot challenge' makeup trend
on
Get link
Facebook
X
Pinterest
Email
Other Apps
James Charles is going through backlash for taking part in a well-liked TikTok pattern that imitates mugshots.
The "mugshot problem" originated on TikTok, which started idealizing mugshots lengthyearlier thancustomersbegan mimicking them. In early March, customers posted movies of mugshots they thought had beenengaging.
"Finalwomanappears like she is aware ofhow one can have a gooooood time," one person captioned their video, which now has 226,700 likes.
In one other video, the TikTok person added thirst emojis earlier than launching right into a slideshow of anonymous, incarcerated faces.
The pattern bore the mugshot problem, by whichcustomers recorded themselves making use of smudged eyeliner and messing up their hair earlier than posing in entrance of clean, white partitions. Some took the patternadditional by includingmake-upto seem bruised and bloody. In one version, TikTok person nehvjones utilizeda brief tattoo to her neck. In another, TikTok person thehumankind appeared scratched, including that she "aint happeningand not using acombat."
Picture: TikTok / thehumankind
Picture: tiktok / nehvjones
TikTok creators additionally took the pattern to Twitter, the place they posted images of their makes an attempton theproblem.
The mugshot problem is massively problematic. It supplies a platform to flex make-upabilities, nevertheless itadditionally glamorizes incarceration, which disproportionately affects Black and Latinx communities. Taking partwithin theproblem is insensitive and ignorant, as marginalized communities are already subjected to racial profiling and police brutality. Glamorizing that injustice, even when others are doing it, is mistaken.
The TikTok customersbecoming a member of the pattern with hashtags like #mugshot, which has 135.6 million views, and #mugshotchallenge, 72.7 million views. One otherstandard tag is #mugshotshawty, which has 9.eight million views. Individuals overwhelmingly seem like white. Whereas the pattern is in poor style, it did not garner important criticism tillmagnificence vlogger James Charles jumped on the bandwagon. Charles, who's seen his fair share of controversy, tweeted side-by-side images of himself on Sunday with a bloodied nostril and bruised eye. He did not caption it. Different Twitter customersreferred to as him out for depicting violence and being insensitive. One fan expressed her discomfort, and in contrast it to surviving home violence.
"It isn'tenjoyable having your face bruised and neverhaving the ability tocowl them up," the fan responded to Charles' tweet. "PerhapsI am being too delicatehowever this made me actually uncomfortable as a result ofI could not take mine off. It made me really feel dehumanized."
Charles defined that he was taking part in a TikTok pattern, and that it "has nothing to do with home violence in anyway."
hello babe, I’m so sorry that you just went viaone thing so terrible and traumatic. it’s a tik tok pattern going roundthe placefolksput up their “mugshots” and has nothing to do with home violence in anyway. love you
One other Twitter personfamous that even when Charles was taking partwithin the mugshot problem, there was nothing within theimages indicating that it is a mugshot. With no caption or visible cues, it appeared like Charles had simply been crushed.
Sorry howeverthis doesn'tappear like a mugshot, it's important to know that. There is not anyvisible cue that it's and no caption. It's important tono less thanperceive that. You may of performedone thing to make it clear. This simply missed the mark personally as an evidence.
All through Monday, Twitter customersreferred to as out everybodytaking partwithin the mugshot problem for being privileged and out of contact with these most affected by incarceration. It isvalue noting that most of the TikTok customerstaking partwithin theproblem are younger and might not beconscious of how injust the jail system actually is — however when influencers like Charles use their expansive platforms to hitch the mugshot problem, it provides legitimacy.
"It is aactuality that many brown and black folksshould face, and to decrease this into some patternis admittedlybizarre and gross," Twitter person yojogn mentioned.
the best way brown and black folks are being criminalized disproportionately is disgusting. This pattern is tasteless and takes away from issues with the jail industrial complicated and legislation enforcement system.
Others identifiedsimply how ridiculous the problem is.
I’m sorry however WHAT is that this “make your individual mugshot pattern”?? I apologize {that a} white four on the hotness scale has to inform you this however none of you look sizzling with faux blood and bruises 🤡🤡🤡
Black and Brown folks face disproportionate charges of incarceration, however yts are turning faux mugshot pics right into apattern? 🥴 https://t.co/m8RfGL9jqz
yall and that dumb ass mugshot pattern...... id wager 99% of yall don’t have anybody in your households locked within thejail industrial complicated. Eat a dick.
ur telling me a "mugshot" has develop into a pattern. doing make-up to appear likeyou have gotten beat and brutalized by police. yk POC really get beat by police and brought to precincts for mugshots, half of the time only for being black. after they see us shoulda taught ya smth https://t.co/wmQQ5MvVIt
The general publicis very vexed with celebrities and influencers throughout this pandemic. A number of weeks in the past, a coalition of celebrities (just about) gathered to sing a cover of John Lennon's "Imagine."Howeveras a substitute of inspiring the general public, they had beenslammed for being naïve and privileged. Whereas1000's of symptomatic persons arepreventing to be examined for COVID-19, influencer Arielle Charnas was accused of utilizing her connections to entry testing. Different influencers had beenaccused of "milking the coronavirus for clout." Though the coronavirus pandemic has been known as "the nice equalizer," it evidentlyaffects working class and low-income folksessentially the most.
So when a celeb like James Charles participated within the mugshot problem — which already has its barbs — the general public was lower than welcoming.
Charles, who deleted the tweet on Monday afternoon, issued a non-apology.
"Even thougha whole bunch of different influencers and artists have performedone thingcomparable, I deleted the mugshot patternas a result of it was by no means my intention to set offanybody," he tweeted. "It is a waste of time attempting to have an open dialogue with individuals who hate me regardless."
He added a peace signal emoji.
After the backlash, streamer Corinna Kopf additionally quietly deleted her mugshot problemimages from Twitter and Instagram. After her tweet was included in a round-up by Pop Crave, characterBianca Dayag made her account non-public.
Charles' supporters dismissed criticism, dismissing it as haters out to get him. And whereas Charles does obtain a fair proportion of criticism, he additionally has an enormous following. As a public determine, his actions will be criticized, particularlyin the event that they're thoughtless of those thatdo not have the privilege he does. Moreover, there are manyother challenges to take part inthat do not glamorize the prison justice system. In the event you or somebodyyou understand has skilledhome violence, name the NationwideHome Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-SAFE (7233) or TTY 1-800-787-3224.
Comments
Post a Comment